OK, OK...I accept in advance I'm going to be flamed as a geek of the highest order, but I don't mind. I'm a huge fan of the books (even though the last one wasnt all that good) and I've been waiting for this to start for months.
On the evidence of the first episode (shown Sunday night in the US, Monday night in the UK...following the trend set by Lost) HBO have done a fantastic job of adapting the first novel. It looks as good as a movie and the casting is (on the whole) spot on.
When I mention it to people they often say "I hate Hobbits and all that shit" so I generally give up after one weary explanation that it's more the War Of The Roses (thats the actual war, not the shit film with Michael Douglas) than walking miles to chuck a ring in a volcano. In fact so broad is the pallete of characters I'd describe it as The Wire with massive swords.
I only say all this because I want people to watch it so HBO will comission a second series (there are 5 books so far with the 6th out later this year). Knowing whats coming up in books 2 and 3 I'd hate to see it canned after one season.
Don't know about the US but the UK press have been giving it really good coverage and reviews so fingers crossed!
I'll shut up now.
http://www.metro.co.uk/tv/reviews/86117 ... -of-merlin
http://www.guardian.co.uk/tv-and-radio/ ... ucy-mangan
http://www.guardian.co.uk/tv-and-radio/ ... NTCMP=SRCH
(runs and hides)